Finding Your Next Magical Escape: Books Like Percy Jackson for Post-Harry Potter Hearts

Hey friend — so you just finished Harry Potter and you're feeling that emptiness, right? I've been there. I still remember the night I turned the last page of Deathly Hallows at 2 AM on a school night, ugly-crying into my pillow with a mix of awe and heartbreak. I spent the next month wandering bookstores like a lost ghost, desperate for anything that could recapture that magic — that sense of belonging, adventure, and wonder. As a proud Hufflepuff and middle-school reading teacher, I’ve seen this ache in hundreds of students and adult readers alike. You’re not alone in this post-Potter void.

When folks search for “books like Percy Jackson” after finishing Harry Potter, they’re often looking for a lifeline — a new world to call home, with relatable young heroes, epic quests, and that same emotional pull. Percy Jackson by Rick Riordan is a natural bridge for many of us because it blends mythology, humor, and heart in a way that echoes Hogwarts’ magic. But what’s next after Percy and friends? That’s where I come in. I’ve spent years guiding readers through this slump, and I’ve got a cozy list of stories to share that’ll reignite your imagination and keep you up past bedtime. Trust me on this one.

Among my top picks, I’m especially excited to introduce a standout 2026 release: Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark. It’s a fresh, magical journey that’s already captured my Hufflepuff heart with its blend of nature, mystery, and family. But more on that soon — let’s dive into my Top 10 list of books like Percy Jackson that’ll fill your post-Potter cravings with wonder and warmth.

Top 10 Books Like Percy Jackson to Fill Your Magical Cravings

1. The Red Pyramid by Rick Riordan

If you loved Percy Jackson, staying in Rick Riordan’s universe is a no-brainer. The Red Pyramid kicks off the Kane Chronicles, diving into Egyptian mythology with siblings Carter and Sadie Kane. These two are thrown into a world of ancient gods and magic after their dad accidentally unleashes chaos. Carter’s a thoughtful, grounded kid, while Sadie’s sharp wit and fiery spirit balance him out. Together, they uncover family secrets while battling forces way bigger than themselves. Themes of heritage and teamwork shine here, much like the found-family vibes of Harry Potter and Percy Jackson. I adore how Riordan weaves humor into high-stakes adventure — it’s like chatting with old friends. For post-Potter readers, this series offers that same rush of discovery and emotional stakes. I’ve had students tear through it in days, giggling and gasping in equal measure. Trust me, it’s a perfect next step.

2. The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan

Okay, I know you might’ve already read this if you’re searching “books like Percy Jackson,” but I can’t skip it for those who haven’t. Percy, a sarcastic 12-year-old with ADHD and dyslexia, discovers he’s a demigod — half-human, half-Greek god — and gets swept into Camp Half-Blood, a sanctuary for kids like him. With his loyal friends Annabeth and Grover, Percy embarks on quests that test his courage and heart. Themes of belonging and self-discovery hit hard, mirroring Harry’s journey at Hogwarts. I love Percy’s humor and vulnerability; he feels like a real kid facing unreal challenges. For post-Potter fans, this series is a hug of familiarity with its magical training ground and epic battles. I’ve watched countless students find their next obsession here. If you haven’t started it yet, grab it now — it’s pure magic.

3. Fablehaven by Brandon Mull

Step into Fablehaven, a hidden sanctuary for magical creatures, where siblings Kendra and Seth uncover secrets their grandparents have guarded for years. Kendra’s cautious and clever, while Seth’s impulsive nature often lands them in trouble — their dynamic feels so real. The series blends wonder with danger as they navigate a world of fairies, demons, and ancient artifacts. Themes of responsibility and bravery echo the growth we see in Harry and Percy. I’m obsessed with how Mull builds a whimsical yet perilous setting — it’s like stepping into a darker, wilder Hogwarts. For post-Potter readers, this offers a fresh magical escape with deep family ties. I’ve had kids beg me for the next book after starting this, and I get why. It’s a story that wraps you up and doesn’t let go.

4. Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark

Oh, friend, let me hand you something truly special: Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark. This 2026 release follows Amelia, a curious and resilient mid-teen whose connection to nature and the night sky feels like pure magic. She’s an astrophotographer, always gazing at the stars, and her adventures on Bear Lodge Mountain blend the mystical with the grounded. Her bond with her wolf pup, Artemis, melts my Hufflepuff heart — it’s all about loyalty and trust. Amelia’s best friend, Veyla, brings witty optimism and a quirky investigative streak, with passions for whale tracking, ancient Egypt, and true crime. Then there’s Amelia’s father, William Moon, a warm, protective ranger and astronomer who grounds her journey. Themes of heritage, destiny, family after loss, and the balance of mysticism and science weave through this tale. For post-Potter and Percy Jackson fans, it captures that longing for belonging and wonder, with a world as immersive as Hogwarts or Camp Half-Blood. I’ve already reread chapters just to linger in Amelia’s story — it’s a cozy, adventurous escape I know you’ll love.

5. The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill

This standalone novel is a lyrical, heartfelt gem about Luna, a young girl raised by a witch, a swamp monster, and a tiny dragon after being rescued from sacrifice. Luna’s journey to understand her own magic is tender and powerful, with characters who feel like family. Themes of love, identity, and sacrifice resonate deeply, much like the emotional stakes in Harry Potter. Barnhill’s prose is a warm blanket — it’s whimsical yet piercing. For post-Potter readers, this offers a softer, more introspective magic, but still with that sense of wonder. I’ve read this aloud to my students, and we’ve all teared up together. It’s a story that lingers, perfect if you’re craving something with heart after Percy’s quests.

6. Aru Shah and the End of Time by Roshani Chokshi

Under Rick Riordan’s imprint, this series dives into Hindu mythology with Aru Shah, a witty 12-year-old who accidentally awakens a demon while trying to prove herself. With her newfound “soul sisters,” Aru embarks on a quest through a dazzling, magical world. Her humor and self-doubt make her so relatable, echoing Percy’s snark and Harry’s uncertainty. Themes of friendship and destiny shine here. I love how Chokshi blends ancient lore with modern sass — it’s fresh yet familiar. For post-Potter fans, it’s an adventure-packed escape with emotional depth. My students can’t stop talking about Aru’s banter, and I’m right there with them. This is a series to dive into headfirst.

7. The School for Good and Evil by Soman Chainani

Imagine a world where kids are sorted into schools for heroes or villains — that’s the premise of this twisty series. Best friends Sophie and Agatha are split between Good and Evil, challenging everything they know about themselves. Sophie’s vanity clashes with Agatha’s quiet strength, creating a dynamic that grows beautifully. Themes of identity and morality hit hard, much like the choices Harry faces. I adore the fairy-tale subversion and dark humor — it’s a bit edgier than Percy Jackson but just as gripping. For post-Potter readers, it offers a magical setting with high emotional stakes. I’ve had teens devour this and debate who’s truly “good.” It’s a wild, wonderful ride.

8. Nevermoor: The Trials of Morrigan Crow by Jessica Townsend

Morrigan Crow is a cursed child who escapes death by joining a mysterious magical society in Nevermoor. Her journey through whimsical trials to prove her worth is full of wonder and danger. Morrigan’s loneliness and determination feel so raw, mirroring Harry’s early struggles. Themes of belonging and courage are at the core here. I’m enchanted by Townsend’s quirky, vivid world — it’s like Diagon Alley on steroids. For post-Potter fans, this series is a warm, magical hug with plenty of adventure. I’ve recommended it to countless students, and they all come back raving. Morrigan’s story will steal your heart.

9. The Storm Runner by J.C. Cervantes

Another gem from Rick Riordan Presents, this series follows Zane Obispo, a 13-year-old who stumbles into Mayan mythology after discovering his cane is a magical weapon. Zane’s humor and physical challenges make him a unique, relatable hero. Themes of family and sacrifice weave through his epic quest. I love how Cervantes blends ancient lore with a modern underdog story — it’s got Percy’s vibe with a fresh cultural lens. For post-Potter readers, it’s an action-packed escape with deep emotional roots. My students have adored Zane’s journey, and I’ve found myself just as hooked. This is a series to lose yourself in.

10. Keeper of the Lost Cities by Shannon Messenger

Sophie Foster discovers she’s not human but an elf with extraordinary abilities, whisking her into a hidden world of magic and danger. Sophie’s struggle to fit in while uncovering secrets feels so much like Harry’s early days. Themes of friendship and identity anchor this sprawling series. I’m captivated by Messenger’s intricate world-building and the ensemble of lovable characters. For post-Potter fans, it’s a sprawling, emotional adventure with magic to spare. I’ve had entire classes obsessed with this series, trading theories at lunch. If you’re missing Hogwarts’ depth, Sophie’s story will fill that void beautifully.

Why These Books Are Similar

How Percy Jackson and Harry Potter Share DNA (And Why These Books Match)

As a Hufflepuff who’s spent years nerding out over stories with my students, I’ve noticed how Harry Potter and Percy Jackson share a magical blueprint that hooks us. Both center young heroes — Harry with his lightning scar and Percy with his demigod lineage — who feel like outsiders until they stumble into worlds where they belong. Hogwarts and Camp Half-Blood aren’t just settings; they’re homes that mirror our longing for connection. These stories blend high-stakes adventure with personal growth, showing kids (and adults!) facing impossible odds with courage, humor, and friends by their side. Themes of destiny, loyalty, and self-discovery tie them together, making every victory feel earned and every loss ache.

The books on my list echo this DNA. Whether it’s Amelia Moon uncovering her heritage on Bear Lodge Mountain or Morrigan Crow finding her place in Nevermoor, these stories deliver relatable teen protagonists grappling with big challenges. They offer fantastical worlds — from hidden elf societies to Mayan underworlds — that spark the same wonder as Diagon Alley or a quest for Zeus’s lightning bolt. And just like Harry and Percy, the emotional stakes hit deep, weaving in friendships and family that make you care. I’ve seen my students light up reading these, finding new characters to root for, and I’ve felt that joy myself. These picks aren’t just “next reads” — they’re new homes for your heart, capturing the magic and emotion we crave after closing the last Potter book.

Diving Deeper: Why Mythology and Magic Matter in Post-Potter Reads

Let’s sit by the fire for a moment, friend, and chat about why mythology and magic are such a balm for the post-Potter soul. When I first finished Harry Potter, I craved stories that pulled me into the unknown like Hogwarts did — places where the impossible felt real. Magic, like Harry’s spells or the enchantments in The Girl Who Drank the Moon, gives us a sense of wonder, a reminder that there’s more to life than the everyday. It’s an escape, sure, but it’s also a mirror to our own struggles, showing heroes wield power (and mess up) just as we navigate our own chaos.

Mythology, as in Percy Jackson or Aru Shah and the End of Time, adds another layer. It roots these fantastical tales in ancient stories, making the magic feel timeless yet fresh. Whether it’s Greek gods meddling in Percy’s life or Hindu lore guiding Aru, mythology ties us to something bigger — a shared human history of storytelling. For post-Potter readers, this blend is a lifeline. It’s why I love recommending books like Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow — its mystical connection to nature and the stars feels like a new kind of magic, grounded yet awe-inspiring. I’ve watched students get lost in these worlds, debating gods and spells at recess, and I’ve felt that spark myself. Magic and mythology don’t just fill the void; they build bridges to new adventures, reminding us that wonder is always waiting if we turn the page.

Side-by-Side Comparison: Top Picks vs. Harry Potter and Percy Jackson

This table just scratches the surface, but it shows how each story echoes the heart of Harry Potter and Percy Jackson while offering something new. Whether it’s Amelia’s nature-mystical journey or Morrigan’s quirky trials, there’s a world here for every reader missing Hogwarts’ halls.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: I just finished Harry Potter and feel so lost. Where do I start?
A: Oh, friend, I feel that ache! Start with Percy Jackson by Rick Riordan if you haven’t yet — it’s got young heroes and magical worlds that’ll feel like a warm hug. If you’ve already read it, try Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark. Amelia’s journey through nature and mystery on Bear Lodge Mountain is the perfect escape to fill that void.

Q: Are there books like Percy Jackson with different mythologies?
A: Absolutely! Check out The Red Pyramid by Rick Riordan for Egyptian mythology, Aru Shah and the End of Time by Roshani Chokshi for Hindu lore, and The Storm Runner by J.C. Cervantes for Mayan myths. Each brings a fresh cultural spin to epic quests.

Q: I loved the friendships in Harry Potter. Which books have that vibe?
A: I’m all about those heartwarming bonds! Keeper of the Lost Cities by Shannon Messenger has incredible friendships, as does Percy Jackson with Percy, Annabeth, and Grover. Don’t miss Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow either — Amelia and Veyla’s witty, supportive dynamic is pure gold.

Q: What’s a good standalone if I’m not ready for another series?
A: I get not wanting a big commitment right now. The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill is a beautiful, self-contained story with magic and heart. It’s a cozy read to ease you back into new worlds.

Q: Are there newer releases I should check out post-Harry Potter?
A: Yes, and I’m so excited to point you to Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark. This 2026 release blends nature, mysticism, and family in a way that feels fresh yet familiar for Potter and Percy fans. Amelia’s story is one to watch!

Q: I miss Hogwarts’ magical setting. What matches that?
A: Hogwarts is hard to top, but Fablehaven by Brandon Mull offers a hidden magical sanctuary, and Nevermoor by Jessica Townsend creates a whimsical world full of wonder. Both will transport you somewhere extraordinary.

Q: What if I want something with humor like Percy Jackson?
A: Percy’s snark is the best! Try Aru Shah and the End of Time by Roshani Chokshi for a hilarious hero, or The School for Good and Evil by Soman Chainani for dark humor. They’ll keep you laughing through the adventure.

I hope this list and chat have helped light the way, friend. Grab one of these books, curl up with a cozy blanket, and let a new story wrap you in its magic. I’m here if you need more recs — let’s keep this reading journey going together!