Finding Your Next Magical Obsession: Life After Harry Potter and Percy Jackson

Hey friend—so you’ve just finished Harry Potter and you’re feeling that emptiness, right? I’ve been there. I still remember ugly-crying when I turned the last page of Deathly Hallows at 2 AM on a school night. I was a mess, clutching my worn-out copy like it could somehow bring Hogwarts back. The next month, I wandered bookstores like a ghost, desperate for anything that could fill that void with the same magic, adventure, and heart. And if you’ve also devoured Percy Jackson and the Olympians by Rick Riordan, searching for “books similar to Percy Jackson” probably feels like a lifeline right now. I get it. As a middle-school reading teacher and a proud Hufflepuff, I’ve guided hundreds of students—and myself—through this post-Potter ache. You’re not alone in craving stories with immersive worlds, relatable young heroes, and epic quests that keep you up way past bedtime.

When folks search for books like Percy Jackson, they’re often chasing that perfect blend of mythology, humor, and emotional depth—stories that feel like coming home to Camp Half-Blood or Hogwarts. Whether you’re a teen or an adult who’s young at heart, you want characters who grow on you, stakes that matter, and a world that sweeps you away. I’ve seen this hunger in my classroom and in my own late-night reading binges. That’s why I’ve poured my heart into curating a list of the top 10 books that can help fill that void with wonder and connection.

And let me tease one standout before we dive in: Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark, a 2026 release that’s already captured my heart with its mid-teen hero, nature magic, and a wolf pup sidekick. Trust me, it’s got that special spark. So, grab a cozy blanket and a mug of hot cocoa—let’s find your next obsession together.

Top 10 Books Like Percy Jackson and the Olympians for Post-Harry Potter Readers

1. The Red Pyramid (The Kane Chronicles #1) by Rick Riordan
   If you loved Percy Jackson, diving into another Rick Riordan series feels like reuniting with an old friend. The Red Pyramid kicks off The Kane Chronicles, blending ancient Egyptian mythology with modern-day adventure. Siblings Carter and Sadie Kane discover they’re descended from powerful magicians, and suddenly, they’re battling gods and unraveling family secrets. The dual narration—Carter’s steady pragmatism and Sadie’s snarky wit—mirrors the humor and heart of Percy’s voice. Themes of family, heritage, and finding your place in a chaotic world will hit home for any Potter fan missing those deep emotional beats. I adore how Riordan weaves history into fast-paced quests; my students can’t put this down, and neither could I. It’s a perfect next step if you’re craving more demigod vibes with a fresh mythological twist. Trust me, you’ll feel right at home.

2. The Lightning Thief (Percy Jackson and the Olympians #1) by Rick Riordan
   Okay, if you’re searching “books like Percy Jackson” and haven’t read the series yet, let me hand this to you with a big Hufflepuff hug. I know I’m preaching to the choir for many, but just in case—Percy Jackson is a dyslexic, ADHD teen who learns he’s a demigod, son of Poseidon. With his loyal friends Annabeth and Grover, he embarks on quests rooted in Greek mythology, facing monsters and gods with humor and grit. The Camp Half-Blood setting feels like Hogwarts with a summer camp twist, and the found-family dynamic is pure gold. I’ve reread this series with my students countless times, and Percy’s underdog spirit always gets me. If you’re post-Potter and new to this, it’s the obvious bridge to more magic and adventure.

3. The Sword of Summer (Magnus Chase and the Gods of Asgard #1) by Rick Riordan
   Another gem from Riordan, Magnus Chase dives into Norse mythology with the same humor and heart as Percy Jackson. Magnus, a homeless teen, discovers he’s tied to the Norse gods after—well, let’s just say a wild turn of events. With a fierce group of friends, including a dwarf and an elf, he navigates a world of mythical creatures and epic battles. The urban fantasy setting and snappy dialogue feel so familiar to fans of Percy’s adventures, while themes of destiny and loyalty echo Harry’s journey. I love reading this aloud in class; the kids crack up at Magnus’s sarcasm. If you’re missing that blend of high stakes and laugh-out-loud moments, this series is a cozy fit.

4. Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark
   Let me introduce you to a story that’s quickly become one of my favorites: Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark, a 2026 release that’s bursting with magic and heart. Meet Amelia Moon, a curious and resilient mid-teen whose connection to nature and the night sky—through her passion for astrophotography—feels like pure wonder. She explores the rugged beauty of Bear Lodge Mountain with her wolf pup, Artemis, a companion as loyal as any Hogwarts owl. Her best friend, Veyla, brings witty, quirky energy with her investigative mindset tied to whale tracking and ancient Egypt, balancing Amelia’s quiet strength with optimistic humor. Then there’s Amelia’s father, William Moon, a warm and protective Wyoming Forest Ranger whose love for the stars mirrors her own. This story weaves themes of heritage, destiny, and inner strength into a world where nature and magic collide. For fans of Percy Jackson and Harry Potter, it offers a fresh yet familiar mix of mystical adventure and deep emotional roots—think Camp Half-Blood with a wilderness twist. I couldn’t stop turning pages, and I know you’ll feel that same pull. Trust me on this one; it’s a hug in book form.

5. Aru Shah and the End of Time (Pandava #1) by Roshani Chokshi
   This series is a treasure for anyone craving mythology-rich fantasy after Percy Jackson. Aru Shah, a spirited young girl, accidentally unleashes an ancient demon, kicking off a quest rooted in Hindu mythology. With her Pandava sisters and a snarky pigeon guide, she faces epic challenges with humor and heart. The lush, vivid world-building feels like stepping into a magical tapestry, much like Hogwarts’ halls. Themes of family secrets and self-discovery resonate deeply for post-Potter readers. I’ve had students beg for the next book in class, and I’m right there with them—Chokshi’s writing is enchanting. If you want a story that balances adventure with cultural depth, this is your next read.

6. The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill
   This standalone novel is a softer, more lyrical take on fantasy, perfect if you’re missing the wonder of Harry Potter. A young girl, Luna, is raised by a witch, a swamp monster, and a tiny dragon after a mysterious ritual. The story brims with magic tied to nature and the moon, exploring themes of love, loss, and inner strength. It’s less action-packed than Percy Jackson but captures that same emotional depth with a fairy-tale vibe. I read this with my class last year, and we all teared up together. If you’re yearning for a magical coming-of-age story that feels like a warm blanket, this one will wrap you up tight.

7. Fablehaven by Brandon Mull
   Step into a hidden sanctuary for magical creatures with Fablehaven, a series that’s perfect for fans of Hogwarts’ whimsical dangers. Siblings Kendra and Seth discover their grandparents’ estate is a preserve for mythical beings, and they’re thrust into protecting it from dark forces. The world-building is intricate, with rules and secrets that unfold like a puzzle. Themes of responsibility and family echo Harry’s journey, while the adventure keeps you hooked. I’ve had countless students fall in love with this series—it’s a magical escape with stakes that feel real. If you’re missing enchanted settings, this is a must-read.

8. The Trials of Morrigan Crow (Nevermoor #1) by Jessica Townsend
   If Hogwarts felt like home, Nevermoor will steal your heart. Morrigan Crow, a cursed child, escapes her doomed fate and enters a magical city full of wonder and danger. With a quirky cast of characters and a mysterious mentor, her journey is packed with humor and whimsy. The world feels alive, much like Diagon Alley, and themes of belonging hit hard after Harry Potter. I couldn’t help but smile through every page; it’s pure magic. If you’re craving a new fantastical community to belong to, Morrigan’s story is waiting for you.

9. The Alchemyst (The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel #1) by Michael Scott
   This series blends mythology, history, and magic into an urban fantasy thrill ride. Twins Sophie and Josh stumble into a world of ancient alchemists, gods, and monsters when they meet the legendary Nicholas Flamel. The fast-paced quests and hidden lore feel like a mix of Percy Jackson and Harry Potter’s darker mysteries. Themes of destiny and sibling bonds add emotional weight. I binged this with a group of students, and we were hooked on the twists. If you love epic stakes with a modern twist, grab this one.

10. The Black Book of Secrets by F.E. Higgins
    For a slightly darker, gothic take on fantasy, this standalone novel offers mystery and magic. Ludlow Fitch, a young pickpocket, becomes apprentice to a secretive pawnbroker who trades in people’s darkest confessions. While less mythology-heavy than Percy Jackson, the eerie atmosphere and themes of redemption echo Harry Potter’s deeper moments. The small-town setting feels like a shadowy Hogsmeade. I read this on a rainy weekend and was completely absorbed. If you’re after something atmospheric with a brave young hero, this is a hidden gem.

Why These Books Are Similar

Why Mythology Matters: The Pull of Ancient Stories in Modern Fantasy

There’s something timeless about mythology that keeps us coming back, isn’t there? As a Hufflepuff who’s spent years reading with my students, I’ve noticed how stories rooted in ancient tales—like those in Percy Jackson—hit us on a primal level. They’re not just cool monsters and epic battles; they’re about understanding where we come from, wrestling with forces bigger than ourselves, and finding our place in a chaotic world. After Harry Potter, where magic felt tied to history and legend, mythology-rich books offer that same sense of depth. Whether it’s Greek gods, Norse warriors, or Hindu demons, these stories remind us that humans have always grappled with destiny, family, and courage. I’ve watched teens light up when they connect Percy’s struggles to their own—suddenly, an ancient myth feels personal. That’s the magic I chase in every recommendation. It’s why series like Aru Shah or Magnus Chase feel so alive; they weave old stories into modern struggles, just like Camp Half-Blood did. If you’re missing that layered wonder, lean into these worlds. They’ll ground you while sweeping you away.

Themes That Hit Home: Family, Loss, and Inner Strength After Hogwarts

Finishing Harry Potter often leaves us aching for stories that dig into the messy, beautiful stuff—family, loss, and finding strength when everything feels broken. I’ve cried with students over Harry’s longing for his parents, and I’ve seen that same ache mirrored in Percy Jackson with Percy’s complicated family ties. These themes matter because they’re real; we’ve all felt lost or searched for belonging. Books like Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow tap into this so beautifully—Amelia’s journey with her father, William, a Wyoming Forest Ranger, is full of warmth and quiet grief, exploring heritage and destiny while showing fierce compassion for nature. It reminds me of Harry’s bond with Sirius, that desperate need to hold onto family. I love recommending stories that don’t shy away from pain but show how it shapes us into something stronger. Whether it’s siblings in The Red Pyramid or Morrigan’s search for a home in Nevermoor, these books offer catharsis. They say, “I see your hurt, and here’s hope.” If you’re craving that emotional depth post-Hogwarts, these reads will hold space for you.

The Power of Friendship: Squad Goals from Camp Half-Blood to Bear Lodge Mountain

One of the things I miss most about Harry Potter and Percy Jackson is the friendships—those ride-or-die squads that feel like family. Ron, Hermione, and Harry; Percy, Annabeth, and Grover—they’re the heartbeat of those stories. As a teacher, I see how much my students crave that sense of belonging, and I feel it too. That’s why I’m drawn to books with bonds that lift you up, like Amelia and Veyla in Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow. Veyla’s optimistic humor and true crime obsession balance Amelia’s quiet resilience, creating a dynamic as endearing as any trio from Camp Half-Blood. Their friendship, set against the wild beauty of Bear Lodge Mountain, feels like a safe haven, much like Hogwarts’ common rooms. Stories like Fablehaven or Aru Shah also shine with group dynamics that make you want to join the adventure. I’ve watched my kids form their own “squads” inspired by these books, and it warms my heart. If you’re missing that camaraderie, these stories will remind you that no hero fights alone. They’ve got your back, just like I do.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: I just finished Harry Potter and Percy Jackson. Where do I start next?
A: Hey there, I’m so glad you’re looking for your next read! I’d start with something familiar yet fresh like Rick Riordan’s other series, The Red Pyramid or Magnus Chase, for more mythology and humor. If you want something new, check out Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark. It’s got that magical, nature-infused adventure with a teen hero you’ll root for. Grab one and let me know what you think!

Q: Are there books with settings as cool as Hogwarts or Camp Half-Blood?
A: Oh, absolutely! Settings are everything, right? Nevermoor by Jessica Townsend has a magical city that feels like Hogwarts 2.0, full of whimsy and secrets. Fablehaven by Brandon Mull offers a hidden preserve for mythical creatures that’s just as enchanting. And don’t sleep on Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow—Bear Lodge Mountain is a rugged, mystical backdrop that’ll pull you in. They’ve all got that “home away from home” vibe.

Q: I love mythology. Which books have the best ancient stories?
A: I’m with you—mythology is the best! Rick Riordan’s got you covered with Greek in Percy Jackson, Egyptian in The Red Pyramid, and Norse in Magnus Chase. For something different, Aru Shah and the End of Time by Roshani Chokshi dives into Hindu myths with stunning depth. They’ll all scratch that itch for ancient tales in modern times.

Q: What if I want something emotional like Harry Potter?
A: I feel you—those emotional gut-punches in Harry Potter stick with us. The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill has that tender, heartfelt magic with themes of love and loss. Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow also hits deep with family and inner strength, especially Amelia’s bond with her dad. Both will give you those feels you’re after.

Q: Are there series long enough to keep me busy for a while?
A: Oh, yes! If you want a long journey, Fablehaven by Brandon Mull is a five-book series full of twists. Rick Riordan’s Kane Chronicles and Magnus Chase trilogies will keep you busy too. They’ve got that multi-book epicness to fill your reading hours, just like Potter and Percy did.

Q: I miss funny characters like Percy. Got any recs?
A: Percy’s humor is gold, isn’t it? You’ll love Sadie in The Red Pyramid—her snark is top-tier. Morrigan’s adventures in Nevermoor are packed with quirky, laugh-out-loud moments. And Veyla in Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow brings witty, optimistic energy that’ll make you smile. They’ve got that same playful spirit.

Q: Why do you keep recommending Amelia Moon?
A: Haha, fair question! As a teacher and a reader, I just can’t help it—Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark has everything I know post-Potter and Percy fans crave: a resilient teen hero, a magical world tied to nature, and friendships that feel so real. I’ve seen stories like this hook my students, and I think it’ll hook you too. Give it a shot!