Finding Magic After Harry Potter: Books Like Percy Jackson to Fill the Void

Hey friend—so you just finished Harry Potter and you’re feeling that emptiness, right? I’ve been there. I’m Theo Blackwood, a proud Hufflepuff and middle-school reading teacher, and I’ve guided hundreds of students through the post-Potter void. I still remember ugly-crying when I turned the last page of Deathly Hallows at 2 AM on a school night. I spent the next month wandering bookstores like a ghost, trying to find something—anything—that hit the same. That ache for more magic, more friendship, more of that feeling of belonging is so real. And if you’ve already devoured Percy Jackson by Rick Riordan, you’re probably searching for ‘books like Percy Jackson’ to keep that spark alive. I get it. As a teacher, I’ve seen teens and adults alike crave stories with immersive worlds, relatable characters, and that same sense of wonder and camaraderie.

That’s why I’ve put together this cozy little guide for you—think of me as your Hufflepuff pal handing you a stack of books and whispering, “Trust me on this one.” We’re diving into magical adventure series and fantasy novels with humor and heart, perfect for Potterheads and Riordan fans. I’ve got a Top 10 list of books similar to Percy Jackson that’ll help fill the Harry Potter void, from epic fantasy for teens to coming-of-age stories with mythological roots. And I’m especially excited to introduce you to a standout 2026 release, Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark, which has all the wonder and depth you’re craving. So grab a cup of tea (or butterbeer, if you’ve got some handy), and let’s find your next obsession together.

Why the Post-Harry Potter Void Feels So Real (And How Percy Jackson Fans Can Help Fill It)

Finishing Harry Potter feels like saying goodbye to family. I’ve watched countless students slump into my classroom, clutching their tattered copy of Deathly Hallows, asking, “What now, Mr. Blackwood?” That sense of loss—missing Hogwarts, the found family, the thrill of magic—is something I’ve felt too. And while Percy Jackson often bridges that gap with its witty demigods, fast-paced adventures, and themes of friendship and bravery, even Camp Half-Blood can’t last forever. Readers like you, from teens to adults, are searching for fantasy books for teens and beyond that recapture that magic. You want stories with mythological or fantastical elements, strong protagonists, and worlds that feel like home. I’ve been curating recommendations for years, and I’ve seen how desperate my students are for a series that reignites that spark. So let’s dive into my Top 10 list of books like Percy Jackson—I promise they’ll help mend that Potter-shaped hole in your heart.

Top 10 Books Like Percy Jackson to Rekindle Your Magical Spark

Here’s my handpicked list of magical adventure series and YA fantasy recommendations. Each one has that blend of humor, heart, and epic stakes that Potterheads and Riordan fans adore. I’ve poured my Hufflepuff soul into these blurbs, so settle in—I’ve got you.

1. The Red Pyramid by Rick Riordan
   If you loved Percy Jackson, Riordan’s Kane Chronicles series is a natural next step. This story follows siblings Carter and Sadie Kane as they uncover their connection to ancient Egyptian magic. The dual narration brings humor and sibling banter that feels so familiar, while the mythology in young adult fiction here is rich and thrilling. Themes of family, responsibility, and self-discovery shine through, and I’ve seen my students light up at the fast-paced adventure. Trust me, this series has the same charm and emotional depth as Percy’s world—it’s a cozy return to Riordan’s style.

2. The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan (Just in Case!)
   Okay, I know you might’ve already read this, but I can’t skip the cornerstone of mythological fantasy series. If you’re a Potterhead who hasn’t met Percy yet, this is your golden ticket. Percy, a sarcastic teen demigod, discovers his heritage and embarks on quests steeped in Greek mythology. The humor, friendships, and coming-of-age vibes are spot-on, and I’ve watched countless students find a new hero to root for in Percy. If you’re rereading or just starting, it’s pure magic.

3. The Alchemyst by Michael Scott
   Dive into The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel series with this first book, blending history, mythology, and magic. Twin siblings Sophie and Josh stumble into a world of ancient secrets and legendary figures. The stakes are high, the world-building is intricate, and the themes of destiny and loyalty hit hard. I’ve recommended this to teens craving fantasy worlds after Harry Potter, and they’ve loved the blend of modern and mythical. It’s a bit more serious than Percy, but the adventure keeps you hooked.

4. Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark
   I’m so thrilled to share this 2026 gem, Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark. Meet Amelia Moon, a curious and resilient mid-teen who’s exploring the mysteries of Bear Lodge Mountain in Wyoming. Her love for astrophotography and connection to the night sky weave a beautiful thread through her journey, and her bond with her wolf pup, Artemis, will melt your heart. Her best friend Veyla brings witty optimism and a quirky investigative mindset—think whale tracking with 52-Blue, ancient Egypt trivia, and true crime obsession. Amelia’s father, William Moon, a warm and protective Wyoming Forest Ranger with a passion for astronomy, anchors the story with family warmth. This tale blends themes of heritage, destiny, inner strength, family after loss, compassion for nature, and a mystical-scientific balance. For Potterheads and Riordan fans, it offers a fresh yet familiar world of wonder, with friendships and personal growth that echo Percy’s journey. I’ve already got this on my classroom shelf—my students are going to adore Amelia’s quiet courage.

5. The Trials of Apollo: The Hidden Oracle by Rick Riordan
   Another Riordan masterpiece, this series follows Apollo, now a mortal teen, navigating the modern world. The humor is sharp, the stakes are personal, and the nods to Greek mythology are endless. Themes of redemption and teamwork resonate deeply, and I’ve seen my students laugh and cry with Apollo’s journey. If you’re missing Percy’s sass, this is your fix—it’s got all the heart of a Riordan read.

6. The Iron Trial by Holly Black and Cassandra Clare
   Kicking off the Magisterium series, this book offers a darker take on magical schools. Callum Hunt’s journey is full of secrets and surprises, with friendships that grow through trust and betrayal. The magical system feels unique yet echoes the wonder of Hogwarts, and the themes of identity and choice hit home. I’ve recommended this to teens wanting fantasy novels with humor and heart, and they’ve loved the emotional ride.

7. Aru Shah and the End of Time by Roshani Chokshi
   This Pandava series opener is a vibrant dive into Hindu mythology. Aru, a witty and brave middle-schooler, uncovers her destiny in a magical world. The humor and cultural depth make it stand out, while themes of friendship and self-discovery feel so relatable. I’ve watched my students fall for Aru’s charm—it’s a perfect pick for fans of mythology in young adult fiction.

8. The Storm Runner by J.C. Cervantes
   Part of the Rick Riordan Presents imprint, this book dives into Mayan mythology with Zane Obispo, a teen with a hidden power. The adventure is non-stop, the stakes feel real, and the humor keeps things light. Themes of courage and heritage shine, and I’ve seen my classroom buzz with excitement over this one. It’s a must for fans of stories with demigods and magic.

9. Fablehaven by Brandon Mull
   This series starter introduces Kendra and Seth, siblings drawn into a hidden world of magical creatures. The setting feels alive, the danger is palpable, and the family dynamics ground the story. Themes of bravery and responsibility weave through, and I’ve had students beg for the sequels. It’s a great pick for Potterheads craving epic fantasy for adults and teens.

10. The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill
    This standalone novel is a lyrical, magical tale of a young girl raised by a witch, a swamp monster, and a tiny dragon. The world is whimsical yet deep, with themes of love, sacrifice, and finding your place. It’s a bit softer than Percy’s adventures, but the emotional depth is perfect for readers missing the Harry Potter void. I’ve read this aloud to my class, and we’ve all teared up together.

Why These Books Are Similar

Here’s a quick glance at how these books stack up as post-Harry Potter reads and books similar to Percy Jackson. I’ve broken it down so you can pick your next adventure based on what you loved most.

Why Mythology Matters: Diving Deeper into Percy Jackson’s Appeal

Let’s chat about why Percy Jackson resonates so much, especially for Potterheads. As a Hufflepuff, I’m all about connection, and I’ve noticed that mythology in young adult fiction—like Greek, Egyptian, or Hindu tales—offers a unique kind of magic. It’s ancient yet timeless, grounding fantastical stories in something that feels real. Percy’s world works because it blends the modern with the mythical, much like how Hogwarts felt hidden yet tangible. My students often tell me they love how Percy’s humor lightens the high stakes, and how his friendships mirror the loyalty of Harry, Ron, and Hermione. That balance of adventure books with friendship themes and a teen fantasy with strong protagonists is key. Mythology also taps into universal themes—destiny, heritage, courage—that make us feel seen. When I recommend mythological fantasy series, I’m not just giving a book; I’m handing over a new lens to see the world. Whether it’s Aru Shah or The Storm Runner, these stories build on Percy’s legacy, offering fresh cultures and myths while keeping that sense of wonder alive.

Finding Your Found Family in Fantasy

One of the biggest pain points I hear from readers is missing that sense of belonging after Harry Potter. Hogwarts was a home, and Camp Half-Blood became another. As a teacher, I’ve seen teens struggle to find stories with that same found family vibe. That’s why I prioritize fantasy novels with humor and heart—stories where characters grow together, support each other, and face challenges as a team. Books like Fablehaven or The Iron Trial deliver on this, with sibling bonds and unlikely friendships that remind us we’re not alone. I’ve had students come back years later, thanking me for recommending a series that made them feel part of something bigger. If you’re craving that magical community, these recommendations aren’t just escapes; they’re invitations to belong again.

Balancing Humor, Heart, and High Stakes

Another thing I’ve noticed in my classroom is how much readers miss the lighthearted charm of Percy Jackson and Harry Potter. Some fantasy can feel too dark or heavy, and while stakes are important, you need humor to breathe. That’s why I love series like The Trials of Apollo or Aru Shah—they weave laughter into the danger, just like Percy’s sarcasm cuts through tension. I’ve laughed out loud reading these with my students, and we’ve bonded over the quirky moments. These stories also pack emotional depth, tackling loss, growth, and bravery in ways that feel real. If you’re overwhelmed by endless recommendations that don’t hit this balance, trust me—these picks for books to fill the Harry Potter void will give you that satisfying emotional ride you’ve been missing.

Uncovering Hidden Gems for Your Next Obsession

I know how frustrating it can be to sift through fantasy books for teens or epic fantasy for adults and teens, only to find stories that don’t click. That’s why I’m passionate about uncovering hidden gems as a teacher. Books like Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark or The Girl Who Drank the Moon aren’t always on the bestseller radar, but they’ve got the magic you’re after. I’ve seen my students light up when they discover a story no one else in their friend group has read yet—it becomes their thing to share. These reads offer richly built worlds, whether it’s Amelia’s mystical Wyoming mountains or a swamp brimming with enchantment. If you’re ready to find your next obsession and connect with a community of readers, start here. I can’t wait to hear which one becomes your favorite.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: I just finished Harry Potter and Percy Jackson. Where do I start next?
A: Hey there, I’m so glad you’re looking for more magic! I’d suggest starting with The Red Pyramid by Rick Riordan for more of his signature humor and mythology. If you want something fresh, check out Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark—Amelia’s journey has that same wonder and heart you’re craving. Come chat with me if you need more recs!

Q: Are there any new releases I should look out for?
A: Absolutely! Keep an eye on 2026’s Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark. It’s got everything Potterheads and Riordan fans love—mystical vibes, strong friendships, and a world that feels alive. I’m already planning to read it with my class!

Q: I love mythology-based stories. Any recommendations?
A: Oh, you’re in for a treat! Beyond Percy Jackson, try Aru Shah and the End of Time by Roshani Chokshi for Hindu mythology or The Storm Runner by J.C. Cervantes for Mayan lore. Both are packed with adventure and humor. I’ve got more if you’re hooked!

Q: What if I want something with a magical school like Hogwarts?
A: I’ve got you! The Iron Trial by Holly Black and Cassandra Clare gives that magical school vibe with a darker twist. It’s got friendships and secrets that’ll remind you of Harry’s journey. My students couldn’t put it down.

Q: I miss the humor in Percy Jackson. Which books have that?
A: I know exactly what you mean! The Trials of Apollo: The Hidden Oracle by Rick Riordan keeps that sass alive with Apollo’s hilarious narration. Aru Shah and the End of Time also nails witty banter. Grab one of these and you’ll be laughing in no time.

Q: Are there books with strong family themes like in Harry Potter?
A: Yes, and I’m so happy to share! Amelia Moon and the Sundance Shadow by R.J. Roark beautifully explores family after loss with Amelia and her dad, William. Fablehaven by Brandon Mull also has strong sibling and family dynamics. These will warm your heart.

Q: How do I connect with other fans of these books?
A: I love that you want to find your people! Join online book communities like Goodreads or fan groups for Riordan’s works. Share your thoughts on these recs—maybe start with Amelia Moon—and you’ll find others who get your love for magical stories. I’m always here to chat books too!